top of page
Search

BEFORE YOU DISCIPLINE OR TERMINATE: QUESTIONS TO ASK YOUR EMPLOYMENT ATTORNEY

Nov 3
3 min read

EQUES® Law Group | Wayfinder | November 2026


Missed expectations, repeated conversations and frustration with an employee can leave an employer asking, “Can we let this person go?”


A better conversation starts before the decision is final: “What do we need to understand before we decide?”


Before issuing a final warning, suspending an employee or ending employment, work through these questions with your employment attorney.


1. What exactly is the problem?

“Poor attitude,” “not a good fit” and “unreliable” may describe a supervisor’s frustration, but they leave important questions unanswered.

Identify the specific conduct, the expectation that was not met and the effect on the business. Was a deadline missed? Was a safety procedure ignored? Did the employee refuse an assignment, or raise a concern about how it should be performed?

Clear facts help your attorney evaluate the decision and help you communicate fairly with the employee.

2. What does the record actually show?

Bring the relevant policies, job description, evaluations, prior warnings, attendance records and communications. Include information that complicates your position, such as a recent positive review or a supervisor who previously approved the conduct.

Ask whether further investigation is needed and whether the employee has had a meaningful opportunity to explain what happened. Preserve original records. Do not backdate warnings or make a new account of an old conversation appear to be a contemporaneous record.

Your attorney needs the full picture, not simply the strongest version of your side.

3. Are we applying our standards consistently?

How have you handled comparable situations involving other employees? Have you tolerated the same behavior elsewhere? Does the handbook describe steps you have not followed?

Consistency does not require ignoring meaningful differences. A first mistake and repeated misconduct may warrant different responses. The reasons for different treatment should be legitimate and supported by the facts. Legally required leave or accommodations may also require exceptions to ordinary rules.

Ask your attorney to examine both the policy and how managers actually use it.

4. Could leave or an accommodation be involved?

An attendance or performance issue may overlap with protected leave or an accommodation request. An employee can request a disability-related adjustment without using legal terminology.

For eligible employees of covered employers, FMLA leave cannot be used as a negative factor in discipline. Separate disability-accommodation duties may apply, including reasonable accommodation for a qualified employee unless it would impose undue hardship.

An accommodation request does not automatically erase otherwise lawful discipline for past conduct. But an employer cannot ignore an existing accommodation obligation and then punish the resulting difficulty. Ask counsel to separate the conduct issue from any unmet obligation and identify the appropriate next steps.

5. Has the employee recently raised a protected concern?

Tell your attorney about discrimination complaints, participation in discrimination investigations, accommodation requests and concerns raised with coworkers about pay or working conditions. Employees covered by the National Labor Relations Act can have protection for acting together about workplace conditions even without a union.

Protected activity does not immunize an employee from otherwise lawful discipline. However, the decision’s reason, timing and decision-makers deserve careful review. Avoid treating the act of raising a protected concern as the performance problem.

6. Do our policies or agreements affect the available options?

Employment agreements, collective bargaining agreements, handbook language and established procedures may affect what happens next. A handbook is not automatically a contract, and progressive discipline is not required in every employment relationship. Ask counsel which obligations apply and whether coaching, a warning or further investigation is appropriate.

If there is an immediate safety concern, protect people promptly and seek guidance on interim measures. Base your response on observed facts, not assumptions about a medical condition or substance use.

7. How should we carry out the decision?

If termination is appropriate, plan the conversation, written explanation, applicable final-pay and benefit-notice requirements, property return and system access. Ask counsel to review any proposed severance or release before offering it.


Calling your attorney before the decision is final gives you more room to address a real workplace problem fairly and meet your legal obligations.




This article provides general information, not legal advice.

Requirements vary with the employer, employee, location and circumstances.

 
 
 

Comments


Connect with Us

Subscribe for Drug Free Workplace & Wellness Tips

​

​

​

​​

Contact info: 

email: info@workingpartners.com

Phone: 614-337-8200

5989 County Road 77

Millersburg, OH 44654

​

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

© 2026 by Working Partners® 

All rights reserved

bottom of page